Skip to main content
Ingenium Logo

You are leaving IngeniumCanada.org

✖


This link leads to an external website that Ingenium does not control. Please read the third-party’s privacy policies before entering personal information or conducting a transaction on their site.

Have questions? Review our Privacy Statement

Vous quittez IngeniumCanada.org

✖


Ce lien mène à un site Web externe qu'Ingenium ne contrôle pas. Veuillez lire les politiques de confidentialité des tiers avant de partager des renseignements personnels ou d'effectuer une transaction sur leur site.

Questions? Consultez notre Énoncé de confidentialité

Ingenium The Channel

Langue

  • Français
Search Toggle

Menu des liens rapides

  • Ingenium Locations
  • Shop
  • Donate
  • Join
Menu

Main Navigation

  • Browse
    • Categories
    • Media Types
    • Boards
    • Featured Stories
  • About
    • About The Channel
    • Content Partners

Off the hook: Canadian aquaculture grows amidst environmental change

Share
10 m
Jun 3, 2021
Categories
Agriculture
Categories
Earth & Environment
Fisheries
Food
Media
Article
Profile picture for user Kyra Simone
By: Kyra Simone
Canada Agriculture and Food Museum
Close-up of a bright, fresh salmon steak with a garnish of herbs.
Photo Credit
Robert Owen-Wahl, from Pixabay

With the longest coastline in the world, Canada has an enduring and complex relationship with commercial fishing. While this industry represents a substantial fraction of the Canadian economy, it has historically brought about massive environmental impacts and threatened the longevity of wild fish populations.

As we enter the United Nations Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development (2021-2030), one of the shared goals of this Ocean Decade is to ensure the long-term sustainability of ocean industries as sources of food and employment. In an era of changing climate and growing food insecurity, aquaculture — breeding, raising, and harvesting fish, shellfish, and aquatic plants — has emerged as an effective complement to harvesting wild fish stocks.

Casting back: History and context

Although similar techniques were practised earlier, fishers in France began to publish and disseminate methods for harvesting and fertilizing fish eggs in the 1840s. The first hatcheries in Canada, built on the Fraser River in the 1890s, reared salmon to restock watersheds affected by intensive fishing, mining, and logging. By the early 1970s, aquaculture had begun to shift towards seafood production amidst growing concern about the overexploitation of wild fish stocks.

As scientists had predicted, Canada's fishing industry experienced a devastating collapse in the 1990s; tens of thousands of jobs were lost, and wild northern cod populations have yet to fully recover. However, demand for fish protein continued to grow as the health benefits of eating fish become more widely known. Globally, through an ongoing "blue revolution" of rapid innovation and improved efficiency, aquaculture surpassed harvesting wild stocks as the main source of seafood in 2014.

Even as fishing practices become more sustainable, aquaculture products remain a vital fraction of seafood production. The impacts of climate change, including warmer water and less dissolved oxygen, make it difficult for fish to survive in the wild. Increased atmospheric carbon dioxide makes water more acidic, which hinders the growth of shells. In the last decade, this ocean acidification has killed tens of millions of scallops.

Within this changing environment, there are also increasing efforts to incorporate Indigenous perspectives, because these groups have sustainably harvested and cultured aquatic species for generations. Three-quarters of rainbow trout in Ontario are now produced in partnership with Indigenous communities, who have deep knowledge of species requirements and environmental interactions.

Though Canada's predominant export is salmon from British Columbia and New Brunswick, facilities across the country raise a variety of finfish, shellfish, and sea vegetables. On the west coast, seaweed with high polysaccharide content is grown to produce agar for food and laboratory use. Prince Edward Island farms are responsible for a substantial fraction of Canada's blue mussels and Eastern oysters. Nova Scotia leads the way in cultivating new species, including clams, scallops, and Irish moss. Even the prairie provinces boast hatcheries and other freshwater facilities.

Aquaculture products represent a third of the economic value from Canada's seafood and in 2018, this fraction amounted to more than $1.4 billion. A forthcoming Aquaculture Act will solidify the federal government's commitment to sustainably growing this profitable sector.

Plenty of fish: Farming methods

Several large nets with circular frames and buoys in calm blue water, with a man on a small motorboat between the nets.
Photo Credit
Asc1733, from Wikimedia Commons.

Net pens at a cage aquaculture site.

The most popular method, cage aquaculture, involves rearing fish in cages or "net pens" within natural water bodies. These systems are the least expensive to establish, and allow water flowing through cages to remove fish waste. However, this method has been heavily criticized for its impacts on wild fish populations and coastal environments. Within the Great Lakes area, Ontario is the only province or state to permit cage cultures, and the anticipated Aquaculture Act may formally move away from this controversial approach.

Large, rectangular ponds surrounded by green fields, with trees in the background. Several people and farm vehicles are visible between ponds.
Photo Credit
United Soybean Board, from Flickr.

A simple pond system for seasonally rearing fish.

A similar concept, pond aquaculture involves raising fish seasonally in natural or constructed ponds. This affords slightly more control over variables such as oxygen content and chemical treatments, and allows water to be treated before release into the environment. Historically, farmers in prairie provinces were encouraged to stock small basins on their property with rainbow trout in spring. These fish eat insects already present in the ponds, and can then be harvested in the fall as a secondary source of income.

Many consecutive rectangular water reservoirs, separated by concrete barriers, with a walkway between them and vehicles parked on an adjacent road.
Photo Credit
Vera Kratochvil, from Wikimedia Commons.

A flow-through raceway facility for trout farming.

Flow-through systems use longer channels with a constant flow of fresh water to culture fish. This technique requires almost 50 times more water than pond aquaculture, but maintains dissolved oxygen levels and allows fish to be cultured at higher densities year-round.

Several rectangular fish tanks, linked by a system of tubing, within a large industrial building. In the background, other tanks and pipes are visible and many cables extend down from the ceiling.
Photo Credit
Narek Avetisyan, from Wikimedia Commons.

A recirculating system, where many finfish are raised under carefully controlled conditions.

Farmers have the greatest control over environmental conditions and waste removal with recirculating systems. These facilities use carefully monitored tanks to maintain precise water temperature and oxygenation. Biofilters with nitrifying bacteria convert ammonia from fish waste into nitrate, and sediments are removed by settling or filtering. Ultimately, more than 95 per cent of water is reused: recirculating systems require 50 times less water than pond aquaculture! With mechanical feeding and oversight over many variables, recirculating systems produce consistent outcomes and large seafood yields all year.

Bait and tackle: Addressing issues

Despite ongoing advances, fish farming continues to encounter resistance, especially concerning its environmental impacts. One criticism is the risk of farmed fish escapes, which could facilitate disease spread and lead to interbreeding or competition with wild fish populations. These concerns primarily relate to cage aquaculture: fish are unlikely to re-enter natural environments from pond or recirculating systems.

Thankfully, few non-native species in the Great Lakes are linked to aquaculture, and they were largely introduced by government agencies stocking areas for sport and commercial fishing. Today, cage-culture facilities use a variety of methods to prevent escapes and limit impacts if farmed fish do enter an ecosystem. Farms use remote-controlled cameras and repair vehicles to address damaged areas of nets. Farmed species may also be unable to survive in natural environments, or unable to breed with wild populations. For example, applying heat and pressure to eggs can produce sterile fish, which have extra chromosomes that make them genetically incompatible with their wild counterparts.

Besides interbreeding, there are also protocols to reduce disease transmission to wild populations. Aquaculturists work closely with veterinarians to monitor for stress and disease. Insecticides have been used for sea lice, but novel methods like pressurized water streams and camera-assisted counting can also address these persistent pests. Fish are vaccinated against common viral and bacterial infections, which makes disease transmission to wild populations highly unlikely. By taking these preventative measures, Canadian fish farmers now use far fewer antibiotics.

Plastic pollution from damaged nets and buoys is also a concern. Nets are moored strongly to the shore at cage culture facilities, and new UV-resistant plastics break down less readily. Some aquaculture plastics are recycled into construction materials, but "biofouling" by accumulated aquatic plants and microorganisms makes this challenging. Recently, nets have been developed from copper alloy mesh, which resists algae buildup and can be fully recycled once decommissioned.

While they are a less overt form of pollution, nutrients from fish waste can cause overgrowths of algae under floating cages. Decomposition of algal blooms uses up dissolved oxygen and can cause die-offs of other aquatic species. Luckily, land-based aquaculture systems can use this phosphorus-rich wastewater as crop fertilizer. Cutting-edge Canadian research has also led to improved feed-conversion efficiency and reduced phosphorus in fish waste! Carnivorous fish were traditionally fed imported fish meal, but the vital omega-3 component is now being replaced with alternatives from grains, algae, and even fisheries byproducts.

As we enter the Ocean Decade, it will be exciting to watch the growth of Canada’s burgeoning aquaculture industry. As the industry transitions to more environmental practices, we will likely see new investments in research and innovation. The tides are changing; aquaculture has enormous potential to bolster food security and the national economy — all while preserving our treasured coastal ecosystems.

Tags
aquaculture, Fisheries and Oceans Canada, fish, cage culture, recirculating systems, pond aquaculture, flow-through system
Author(s)
Profile picture for user Kyra Simone
Kyra Simone
Follow

Kyra is an Environmental Scientist, finishing a master’s degree in Science Communication. Her interdisciplinary background includes an MSc in Biology and research on climate change impacts, at-risk reptiles, and contaminants. As an environmental columnist for the Niagara-on-the-Lake newspaper, The Lake Report, she is passionate about empathetic communication to bring about sustainable change.

Related Stories

A map of the cranberry bog of Les Producteurs de Québec Limitée of Lemieux, Québec. Luc Bureau, “Un exemple d’adaptation de l’agriculture à des conditions écologiques en apparence hostiles: L’Atocatière de Lemieux,” Cahiers de géographie du Québec, December 1970, 389.

“A sea serpent without affidavit, is like roast turkey without cranberry sauce;” Or, how the Larocque family created the first cranberry bog in Québec, part 3

Two images spliced: On the left, different plant-based milk alternatives, on the right, an overhead view of the Spirit rover.

2 things - and more! - you should know about plant-based milk alternatives and weather on Mars

Some of the buildings on the cranberry bog operated by Les Producteurs de Québec Limitée of Lemieux, Québec. Pierre-Arthur Dorion. “La plus importante plantation d’atocas au pays.” Le Bulletin des agriculteurs, July 1955, 11.

“A sea serpent without affidavit, is like roast turkey without cranberry sauce;” Or, how the Larocque family created the first cranberry bog in Québec, part 2

Charles Larocque, manager of Les Producteurs de Québec Limitée of Lemieux, Québec, showing how to pick up cranberries, on the left, as well as fallen fruits floating in water. Arthur Prévost, « À Lemieux, au Québec, prospère la culture des ‘juteux atacas.’ » Photo-Journal, 23 July 1953, 33.

“A sea serpent without affidavit, is like roast turkey without cranberry sauce;” Or, how the Larocque family created the first cranberry bog in Québec, part 1

Left to right: solar panels placed high above low-lying green farm crops in a field; bubbles of various sizes rising in a yellow-green medium; and two tarantula feet magnified 40 times appear orange in colour against a navy-blue background.

3 Things you should know about using the same farmland for producing crops AND solar energy, museum conservators’ superhuman “vision,” and making french fries in space

Two images, spliced. On the left: Aerial photograph of two rows of six large circular nets floating on water and attached by ropes to a boat. On the right: The rings of Saturn slice horizontally, almost edge-on, through the middle of the image. A variety of Saturnian moons of varying apparent sizes are in the image ranging from very small, background moons to larger and closer moons.

2 Things you should know about an integrated aquaculture system and discovering more of Saturn's moons

Spliced image, from left to right: a seismometer on mars, a heap of red rhubarb stalks with green leaves, a copper roof of the Canaian Parliament

3 Things you should know about marsquakes, the value of urine, and the chemistry of rhubarb

A dirty glass slide of a stromatolite with a dirty cotton swab at the bottom; a close-up on a bee with a green head and thorax on a yellow flower; a false colour 3D view of the surface of Venus showing volcanoes and lava flowing towards the foreground.

3 Things you should know about how native bees are important pollinators, how saliva is used to clean artifacts, and active volcanism on Venus

Ahh, ice cream, the cause of and solution to all of life’s problems. I do wonder if this young boy knew he was actually eating mellorine. Anon., “De la crème glacée synthétique.” Photo-Journal, 16 April 1953, 3.

Do they or do they not buy some? Only their grocer knows for sure: A brief look at a lower-cost imitation of ice cream sometimes known as mellorine

A spliced photo, from left to right: Shaun the Sheep in front of a model of ESA’s European Service Module, a top view into a red bucket containing thousands of light-brown, rod-shaped pellets, and a toddler wearing a wool hat and wool sweater holds a grownup’s finger.

3 things you should know about why wool keeps us warm, and about its surprising uses in the garden and in space.

A large impact crater viewed from the rim, a woodern spoon full of small yellow grains, a close up of a forearm being tattooed.

3 things you should know about the untapped potential of millet, the permanence of tattoos, and asteroid airbursts

A promoter of Sure Food, the food chemist James Pearson (right), at the facility of Wentworth Canning Company Limited of Hamilton, Ontario. Anon., “La viande, synthétique, produit canadien, pourrait sauver de la famine les peuples affamés d’Europe.” Photo-Journal, 5 February 1948, 3.

“It smells like meat. It even looks like meat.” The long forgotten tale of a synthetic meat / meat substitute / meat analogue / meat alternative / imitation meat sometimes called Sure Food

Footer

About The Channel

The Channel

Contact Us

Ingenium
P.O. Box 9724, Station T
Ottawa ON K1G 5A3
Canada

613-991-3044
1-866-442-4416
contact@IngeniumCanada.org
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • Channel

    • Channel Home
    • About the Channel
    • Content Partners
  • Visit

    • Online Resources for Science at Home
    • Canada Agriculture and Food Museum
    • Canada Aviation and Space Museum
    • Canada Science and Technology Museum
    • Ingenium Centre
  • Ingenium

    • Ingenium Home
    • About Ingenium
    • The Foundation
  • For Media

    • Newsroom
    • Awards

Connect with us

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive the latest Ingenium news straight to your inbox!

Sign Up

Legal Bits

Ingenium Privacy Statement

© 2023 Ingenium

Symbol of the Government of Canada
  • Browse
    • Categories
    • Media Types
    • Boards
    • Featured Stories
  • About
    • About The Channel
    • Content Partners